By ITM Staff
ITM Plus · Breeders’ Cup Package
Get Even More With ITM Plus
As always, we will have a ton of great, free Breeders’ Cup content, including our Final Answers show, coming up later this week. But if you want to support our channels and get EVEN MORE great info, please sign up to In the Money Plus. There you’ll find proprietary trip notes and speed figures for the foreign horses, in-depth coverage of every race, and grid picks from the entire team, plus all of ITM’s Keeneland Fall Meet coverage.
Join ITM Plus →Twelve previous Breeders’ Cup winners were among the record 255 pre-entries for this year’s World Championships at Keeneland (America’s Best Racing, Oct. 21, 2026). Gstaad has since been withdrawn and Nobals sits outside the field on the also-eligible list, which leaves 10 past winners set to run. If all 10 start, that will tie the record set in 2009 and 2016. The headliner is defending Classic winner Forever Young, who is trying to become only the second horse after Tiznow to win the Classic twice. PTF looks at his chances, and at all 14 defending champions who came back for the Classic, in Can Forever Young defend his Classic crown and emulate Tiznow? for At The Races.
So how do horses do when they come back? Across all 42 Breeders’ Cups, returning winners have won about twice as often as everyone else, but the betting market knows it, and backing all of them blind would have lost money. Where they come back matters more than the fact that they’ve won before.
The record, 1984–2025
Returning winners win about one race in six, but they’re bet like it. “Wins vs. odds” (often called A/E) divides actual wins by the wins implied by final odds, so 1.00 means a group won exactly as often as the prices said. The $2 return is what a $2 win bet on every runner in the group paid back on average.
| Group | Runs | Wins | Win % | Top 3 % | Wins vs. odds | $2 return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All starters | 4,971 | 431 | 9% | 26% | 1.00 | $1.78 |
| Previous BC winners | 178 | 30 | 17% | 43% | 0.95 | $1.30 |
| Defending champions (won the same race the year before) | 103 | 18 | 17% | 45% | 0.91 | $1.20 |
| Juvenile winners now running against older horses | 48 | 5 | 10% | 44% | 0.60 | $0.92 |
| Last BC win two or more years earlier | 36 | 7 | 19% | 39% | 1.45 | $2.03 |
| Previous winners in sprints | 50 | 9 | 18% | 34% | 1.19 | $1.40 |
| Previous winners in dirt routes | 65 | 9 | 14% | 43% | 0.72 | $0.99 |
| Previous winners in turf routes | 63 | 12 | 19% | 49% | 1.05 | $1.55 |
- As a group, they’ve been overbet. A $2 win bet on every returning winner paid back $1.30, well below the $1.78 for all starters. They do hit the board 43% of the time, against 26% for the field.
- Juvenile winners have been the worst bet. Against older horses they’re 5-for-48 with wins vs. odds of 0.60.
- Sprints are the friendliest spot, dirt routes the toughest. Returning winners have beaten their odds in sprints (1.19) and fallen well short in dirt routes (0.72), where the Classic and Distaff weigh heavily.
- Horses whose last BC win came two or more years earlier did best: 7-for-36, including Da Hoss (1998 Mile), Ouija Board (2006 Filly & Mare Turf), Beholder (2016 Distaff) and Rebel’s Romance (2024 Turf). It’s a small group, so treat it as a curiosity rather than an angle.
The last 15 years have been kinder: since 2011, previous winners are 19-for-91 with wins vs. odds of 1.14. As with our trainers and jockeys pieces, samples are small and the patterns may not last.
Feast or famine
In any one year, how many past winners repeat is close to random. In 21 of the 41 years with at least one past winner in the field, none of them won again. Then came 2013, when five did: Secret Circle, Groupie Doll, Mizdirection, Wise Dan and Beholder. The odds pointed to about two. Four years later, nine past winners came back in 2017 and all nine lost.
The size of the crop has grown with the card. The Breeders’ Cup was seven races until 1998 and has been 13 to 15 races since 2008. In the first 24 runnings no year had more than six past winners in the field. Since 2008, nine years have had seven or more.
Defending champions, race by race
The Mile is the race where champions repeat; the Classic and Filly & Mare Turf are where they don’t.
| Race | Defenders | Repeated | Repeat winners |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mile | 13 | 5 | Miesque (1988), Lure (1993), Goldikova (2009, 2010), Wise Dan (2013) |
| Sprint | 17 | 3 | Midnight Lute (2008), Roy H (2018), Elite Power (2023) |
| Turf | 15 | 2 | High Chaparral (2003), Conduit (2009) |
| Turf Sprint | 11 | 2 | Mizdirection (2013), Stormy Liberal (2018) |
| Filly & Mare Sprint | 10 | 2 | Groupie Doll (2013), Goodnight Olive (2023) |
| Dirt Mile | 3 | 2 | Goldencents (2014), Cody’s Wish (2023) |
| Classic | 14 | 1 | Tiznow (2001) |
| Distaff | 9 | 1 | Royal Delta (2012) |
| Filly & Mare Turf | 9 | 0 | — |
| Marathon | 2 | 0 | — |
This year’s returning winners
The 10 past winners set to run, with David Aragona’s pre-entry morning lines for DRF (Oct. 22) and the all-time record of horses in their position.
| Horse | Trainer | 2026 race (ML) | Previous BC win | History, 1984–2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forever Young (JPN) | Yoshito Yahagi | Classic (5/2) | 2025 Classic, 7/2 | Classic defenders 1-for-14 |
| Notable Speech (GB) | Charlie Appleby | Mile (8/5) | 2025 Mile, 5/2 | Mile defenders 5-for-13 |
| Ethical Diamond (IRE) | Willie Mullins | Turf (10/1) | 2025 Turf, 25/1 | Turf defenders 2-for-15 |
| Shisospicy | Jose D’Angelo | Turf Sprint (10/1) | 2025 Turf Sprint, 5/1 | Turf Sprint defenders 2-for-11 |
| Splendora | Bob Baffert | Distaff (9/2), first preference; also Filly & Mare Sprint (5/2) | 2025 Filly & Mare Sprint, 5/2 | F&M Sprint defenders 2-for-10; no F&M Sprint winner has run in the Distaff |
| Cy Fair | George Weaver | Turf Sprint (6/1) | 2025 Juvenile Turf Sprint, 5/1 | Juvenile Turf Sprint winners in the Turf Sprint 1-for-2 |
| Super Corredora | John Sadler | Distaff (20/1) | 2025 Juvenile Fillies, 8/1 | Juvenile Fillies winners in the Distaff 1-for-15 |
| Immersive | Brad Cox | Distaff (30/1) | 2024 Juvenile Fillies, 2/1 | Juvenile Fillies winners in the Distaff 1-for-15 |
| Starlust (GB) | Ralph Beckett | Turf Sprint (20/1) | 2024 Turf Sprint, 33/1 | Last BC win 2+ years ago 7-for-36 |
| Full Serrano (ARG) | John Sadler | Dirt Mile (10/1) | 2024 Dirt Mile, 12/1 | Last BC win 2+ years ago 7-for-36 |
Nobals (2023 Turf Sprint) is 10th on the also-eligible list at 30/1 and is unlikely to draw in. Gstaad (2025 Juvenile Turf) has been withdrawn.
What the history says about this group:
- Notable Speech is in the best spot. Five of the 13 Mile defenders have won again, the best rate of any race, and he’s the 8/5 morning-line favorite.
- Forever Young is up against the toughest record. Only Tiznow (2000 and 2001) has won the Classic twice, and defenders are 1-for-14.
- The Turf Sprint has three past winners in Shisospicy, Cy Fair and Starlust. Golden Pal is the one Juvenile Turf Sprint winner to take the Turf Sprint, in 2021.
- Juvenile Fillies winners rarely win the Distaff. Beholder in 2013 is the only one in 15 tries, which is a hurdle for Immersive and Super Corredora.
How we counted
Records come from the official result charts for every Breeders’ Cup race from 1984 to 2025. A “previous winner” is any starter that had already won a Breeders’ Cup race of any kind. Horses were matched across years by name, with country suffixes removed. As a check, that match finds the 28 horses that have won two or more Breeders’ Cup races, from Miesque and Goldikova to Elite Power and Rebel’s Romance. “Wins vs. odds” divides actual wins by the number implied by each starter’s final win odds, with the odds in each race scaled to remove the takeout. Modern Games, who won the 2021 Juvenile Turf as a non-betting entry, counts as a winner but is left out of the odds figures. Previous winning prices are final odds rounded down to standard fractions. Sprints are races under a mile.
This year’s runners are from the official pre-entries as of Oct. 23, before final entries on Oct. 26 and the draw. Morning lines are David Aragona’s pre-entry lines for DRF (Oct. 22). Our list of returning winners matches the 12 named by America’s Best Racing.
Sources
- America’s Best Racing (BloodHorse), Oct. 21, 2026: Defending Classic winner Forever Young among record 255 pre-entries
- Breeders’ Cup official result charts, 1984–2025
- At The Races (Peter Fornatale), Oct. 19, 2026: Can Forever Young defend his Classic crown and emulate Tiznow?
- 2026 pre-entries (Oct. 23) and David Aragona’s DRF morning lines (Oct. 22)
More Breeders’ Cup 2026: every ITM article, stat pack and video is on our Breeders’ Cup hub.
