Keeneland Full Card Analysis – 4/13/24 – By Eric Solomon

The highlight of this stakes laden Saturday card is the Grade 1 Jenny Wiley for fillies and mares going 1 1/16 miles on the turf. In addition, the final Derby Points Race leading up to the 2024 Kentucky Derby is the Grade 3 Stonestreet Lexington. Both races drew 10 horses with many interesting entrants between them. In addition, the Grade 3 Giant’s Causeway is a turf sprint for fillies and mares which drew an overflow field of 13. First post for the 11 race program is 1:00 (ET).

 

I’ll be covering this exciting meet on the ITM Blog, along with posting some updates and thoughts from time to time on Twitter @EricSolomon718. Feel free to reach out!

 

Race Top Pick A B C Exotics Menu
1 1 1,9,11 DBL, PK3, PK5
2 6 6 3 DBL, PK3, PK4
3 6 1,6,8 9 DBL, PK3
4 10 6,10 9 DBL, PK3, PK4
5 2 2 9 DBL, PK3
6 5 5,7 2 DBL, PK3, PK6
7 6 6 8 DBL, PK3, PK5, All-Turf PK3 (R7,R9,R11)
8 5 5 2,7 DBL, PK3, PK4
9 8 3,8 7 DBL, PK3
10 8 2,5,8 10 DBL
11 3 3,9 4,13

 

Race 1:

The Saturday card begins with a $20K maiden claiming dash at 5 ½ furlongs for fillies and mares. Gloriette (#1) draws the rail in this dash and she has enough speed to get to the front on the drop in class for Ben Colebrook. She blew out a 46:3 bullet four furlong workout over this course a few weeks ago. I think Luan Machado will be riding her to go and the way the course was playing yesterday, that should be a bad thing. Mikey’s Magic Gal (#9) debuts for Aaron West, who has very nice numbers with first time starters since 2023. He’s won with 5 of 16 of them, with one of those three coming at the maiden claiming level. Her works are respectable and she draws a soft field for her debut. She won’t have to be a world beater to score in this race at first asking. Let’s Go Brandi (#11) debuted with $12,500 maiden claimers at the Fair Grounds and she ran well enough to finish second in a narrow defeat. This is a step up in class, but she ran well enough to be considered with this group in start number two. 

 

Race 2:

Eight fillies and mares are set to go seven furlongs in this $80K N2L claiming race. I like St. Benedicts Prep (#6) to score in this spot in what I’m hoping is a Ben Colebrook daily double. He claimed this filly for Arapahoe Thoroughbreds here at Keeneland last fall for $50K on the day she broke her maiden. She was a sharp second in $50K starter allowance company in her next start at Churchill. She ran twice, going a mile both times while competing on the Tapeta at Turfway. She ran credible races in N1X allowance company, but I think these middle distance sprint races at one turn on dirt is where she’s going to be the most effective. Colebrook has great numbers with horses going from routes to sprints, so I think he has the same idea. She has some tactical speed and she should have a decent pace in front of her. I think she’s a better horse now than she was in the fall and I see this as a great spot for her. Theroanrunner (#3) is going to try to play “catch me if you can” in this race. She is the speed of the speed here for Joe Sharp. She drops in class after fading in her last three N1X allowance tries. There isn’t much competition for the early lead, but I do think Liam’s Champ (#4) can keep her honest. She looms as the main danger and she’s worth covering in this spot. However, at longer odds, St Benedicts Prep is more appealing to me. 

 

Race 3:

$40K maiden claimers will go 7 furlongs and 184 feet on the Beard Course in this race. Both Modern Day Warrior (#1) and Unreasonable (#11) defected from a $20K maiden claiming race yesterday, presumably in favor of this race today. Paved in Gold (#6) scratched out of a maiden special weight race on Thursday to run in this spot today. I think this is a much more realistic spot for him, who had no chance against the likes of Jefferson Street that day. He ran well in his debut with $30K-$24K maiden claimers at Laurel two starts ago. He came to Turfway and faded late when facing maiden special weight types in a 6 ½ furlong sprint there. He stretches out to seven furlongs while running with a tag once again. He essentially paired her first two Beyer figures and now takes blinkers off for his third start. He wants to be forwardly placed, which has been an asset this week. The course should be continuing to dry out today after a wet few days of racing this week. I think he can pull the upset in this spot. Modern Day Warrior is trained by Wesley Ward, who is currently atop the leaderboard in the trainer standings at this meet. I did a little deeper dive into Ward’s history with maiden claimers in trying to determine whether or not to use this first time starter on my tickets. His numbers with first time starters are sensational, but I wondered how he fares with debut runners at this distance or longer. When I used the distance filter to see how Ward does with horses debuting at seven furlongs or longer, I saw his strike rate dropped to 10%, way below the norm for him. My inclination was to toss this gelding because there’s no way we’d get appropriate value based upon those stats. However, upon closer investigation, I saw that most of those races within that filter were contested on the grass (which is one reason why I’m playing against Scarlet Poppy in the 5th). He had 16 runners make their debuts on the dirt in the last five years in races contested at seven furlongs or more. Four of them came back as winners, including two on this course. From a pedigree standpoint, the dam was owned and trained by Ward, and she was competitive on the grass in her debut and she won in her second career start on this track at this distance. None of her three foals to race were winners on debut, but they all were competitive. Uncle Mo is a good debut sire, winning with 15% of his runners debuting in dirt sprints. Ward is the owner, trainer, and breeder of this one, and I have no issue with him giving the mount to Jeffrey Sanchez, who is scheduled to ride for the first time since September today. Ward has used him in the past, and they’ve won with 6 of 20 mounts together over the last five years. At the end of the day, the works are decent and I’m going to be putting him on my tickets. Air It Out (#8) is shipping in from the Fair Grounds after faltering when facing a strong maiden special weight field in his last start. He finished second two back in a six furlong sprint, suggesting that he might be best suited for these longer, one turn races. I like him on the drop in class and the cutback in distance. I see both Eirik Ridge (#4) and Summonyourcourage (#12) as horses that could be used underneath, but I’m not using either on top in this race. Instead, I’ll back up with another first time starter, using Beezer (#9) as my deeper saver. Brian Williamson has won with 17% of his debut runners since 2023, however both of those came with maiden claimers. He’s scored with two of five debuting maiden claimers (40%)  in that time span. He has a full sister that was a debut winner and his sire, Bold Warrior has won with 3 of 25 debuting runners (12%) in the last five years. 

 

Race 4:

Ten three year olds are in search of their first career win in this maiden special weight contest at 6 ½ furlongs. Red State (#10) draws the outside for Mike Maker, who is looking for his first winner of the meet. This City of Light colt has been working well in the AM at Churchill. The dam has six starters that have made it to the track and two of them were winners at first asking. City of Light gets 15% debut winners in dirt sprints and Luis Saez takes the mount today. Teen Idol (#6) debuted in a tricky maiden special weight at the Fair Grounds in his most recent start. He was sandwiched at the break and relegated to the back of the field in the first furlong. He made a nice middle move, showing a nice burst of speed along the inside, but she had nowhere to go, and eventually flattened out. I’m not sure how strong of a field she saw in New Orleans, but on paper, this doesn’t appear to be the strongest group either. I think if things go her way in the early stages, she’ll be more competitive today. Shadow Surge (#9) is the lukewarm favorite on the morning line. Irad Ortiz rides this Speightstown colt for George Weaver, who had very good numbers with firsters in 2023. His works aren’t jumping off the page, so I do think there’s a chance that he’ll be overbet in this race. However, his connections and pedigree are enough to make sure I’m at least covered on some tickets with him.

 

Race 5:

The Early Pick-5 ends with a maiden special weight contest for three year old fillies on the turf. This is the first of four races carded on the grass today. The Makers Mark Mile was the only race that was run on the turf all week so far after three days of rain. This course does drain well, so I think with the bad weather hopefully in the rear view mirror, all four grass races will go off as planned today. Assuming this race stays on the grass, I think Spaliday (#2) might be the most likely winner on the card. She’s sired by More Than Ready out of the 2014 turf champion, Dayatthespa. That horse loved this course, winning the Applachian, the QEII Cup, and the First Lady here in her career. This filly was flying late at Gulfstream after swinging wide and being a little green at the top of the lane. While I don’t love another inside draw, I do think the added distance will be a huge plus in her second try. If she stays around her 5-2, I’d be thrilled, but I do worry that she’ll be hammered at the windows. More Than Ready covered another winner of the Breeders’ Cup Filly and Mare Turf, siring Ready for Shirl (#9), who debuts today for Roger Attfield. Perfect Shirl was the upset winner of that race in 2011. She foaled Shirl’s Speight, who was the winner of the 2022 Makers Mark Mile and was 4th in that race yesterday. There are obviously expectations there so that will be where I’ll back up in this spot. 

 

Race 6:

It’s good to see Julia Shining (#2) back on the track after what could only be described as a disappointing three year old campaign. She was 0-5 despite good efforts in the Suncoast, Ashland, and Comely Stakes. She’s a quirky horse that was hard to ride at times. Luis Saez was able to get the most out of her as a two year old, winning two very impressive races here and in the Demoiselle. She’s no doubt the class of this race, but at even money or lower, I’m going to be looking for some horses that could be more forwardly placed. I like Sultry Lass (#5) shipping in from the Fair Grounds for Michelle Lovell today. This will be a huge class test for her, but she’s back on the main track and she should be able to sit a perfect stalking trip, just in behind some of the cheap speed in this race. Her two wins on the dirt in New Orleans were excellent in 2023. She wasn’t as effective on the dirt at Churchill or on the turf at the Fair Grounds this time around. If she likes the local oval, she could prove to be too tough to catch. Musical Mischief (#7) ships in from Southern California for Michael McCarthy after a dull effort in the La Canada Stakes in her last start. Her N1X victory in an off the turf race at Churchill was excellent. While I don’t think she beat much that day, she showed the potential to run that kind of race when she’s at her best. She should also be able to work out a favorable trip in this race. 

 

Race 7, The G3 Giant’s Causeway Stakes:

I see Secret Money (#6) as a major player that is flying under the radar in this spot. She made her first start of the year in the Captiva Island Stakes at five furlongs at Gulfstream. I think she’s the kind of horse that is much more effective at 5 ½ furlongs, which she;s going to get today in this race. She broke her maiden on this course when it was labeled good last spring. She went on to clear the N1X condition at Churchill at this distance as well. She improved throughout the year, almost stealing the Lake George Stakes at one mile on a yielding course at Saratoga and then earning a hard fought Grade 3 victory in the Music City Stakes at Kentucky Downs. She struggled in the last two starts as a three year old, however, she had some excuses. Her 9th place finish in the Valley View came against an above average field at one mile. I think that distance is just beyond the edge of capacity when competing at this level. She tried the Tapeta for the first time in the Holiday Inaugural Stakes at Turfway in December where he finished in the middle of the pack. She now makes her second start off the layoff and she does so on a course and distance where she has had prior success. A softer course favors her and getting that start in at Gulfstream should give her a fitness edge over some of the shorter priced options. I think she’s a major player in this race. Roses for Debra (#8) is the alternative for me, making her first start of the season. She was rolling over the summer, easily winning both of the stakes races at Saratoga for filly and mare sprinters. I would think both the Caress and Smart N Fancy Stakes are on her radar once again this year. With the Grade 2 Intercontinental being run at this distance at Saratoga in June this year, I would think that would be a major goal of hers to point toward. She doesn’t mind a course with some give in it, however the course at Parx proved to be too soft in the Turf Monster there. I’m willing to forgive that effort as I don’t think that course was suitable for racing on that day. She’s a threat, but she might need this race before she’s at her very best. 

 

Race 8:

There is a lot of early speed in this optional claiming/allowance race, and horses that have been forward have done better, we have seen some pace meltdowns on dirt where closers have been able to get home. Giant Game (#1), Transect (#2), Frosted Departure (#3), and Brigadier General (#4), all have run their best races on the lead. Gilcrease (#6) is stretching out to two turns for the first time after starting his career with ten one turn races. This should set the table for either Hayes Strike (#5) and Classic Catch (#7) coming from off the pace. Classic Catch is making his first start since November and he has a little more tactical speed than Hayes Strike. However, his best figures are at 10 furlongs in races that were taken off the turf. In addition, the price differential between Hayes Strike and Classic Catch feels way too wide. I’ll make Hayes Strike the top choice while making his third start off the layoff. He showed flashes of being a really nice horse last year for Ken McPeek. He was very good when winning both the Private Terms and the Texas Derby. However, he struggled in the graded stakes level races that he competed in. McPeek brought him back in an allowance race in New Orleans that was taken off the turf. I think the two races have given him a good foundation and I believe he’s going to get the right setup to run one of his better races at a good number. Classic Catch should get the right setup and Pletcher will likely have him fit. This race may prove to be a bit short for him, but I do see him contending at this level. Transect is the speed horse that makes the most sense to me. With the Romans entry, he’s drawn the rail, giving him inside position on the other runners. He has shown a willingness to sit off the pace if there is a battle up front. Toss his effort on synthetic last out, as the traditional dirt course is his preferred surface. 

 

Race 9, The Grade 1 Jenny Wiley Stakes:

The final Grade 1 race of the spring meet is this 1 1/16 mile turf contest for fillies and mares. This is one of those races that Chad Brown has circled on his calendar every year. He was won six of the last nine editions of this race and he trains four of the ten runners that are entered today. However, I do think there’s a pair of horses from other barns that have a legitimate shot to win this race at decent odds. Star Fortress (#8) is the top pick. She was brilliant in the Grade 3 Cardinal Stakes, catching a good turf course that might have played closer to yielding at Churchill in November. She drew off to win by a whopping ten lengths in that six horse field. While it was a small field, she beat horses that can run as two of the horses she beat have come back to win stakes races over the winter. She had a brutal trip in the Pegasus World Cup Filly and Mare Turf Invitational that was won by Didia (#9). She fell victim to a glacial pace in the Hillsborough Stakes at Tampa, which was run on a firm course. I’m willing to forgive both of those races because after three days of rain during the week, the turf course will still have plenty of give in the ground, which appears to be what this mare craves. Luis Saez rode her at Churchill for her big win there and he gets back aboard today. Elusive Princess (#3) is another runner that should get a big upgrade on a softer course. She also ran in the Hillsborough and was 4th, beaten one length total, and one length in front of Star Fortress. She romped in the Grade 1 Saratoga Oaks Invitational on a soft course in August. She was a decent 4th in the QEII Challenge Cup here in October. She makes her second start off the layoff and should have a forward move after her last race as well. I think these two make a lot of sense in this race. Of the four Chad Brown runners, Surge Capacity (#7) is the one with the most upside. She has five career starts and four wins with a narrow defeat in the Lake Placid last summer. She has a win on the course and a win on yielding ground, so she seems to be more adaptable to the conditions than some of the others in this race. She’s making her first start of the year, but I think Brown has big plans for her 2024 campaign.

 

Race 10, The G3 Stonestreet Lexington Stakes:

I’ve covered this race with horses by horse analysis on the ITM Triple Crown blog, which is linked below. Some quick thoughts on this race are that we are looking at a wide open contest. Encino (#8) is bred to handle the dirt, so I find him interesting when making his first career start on the main track. He’s handled his business well at Turfway and I think the form from the John Battaglia Memorial Stakes is holding up well. Hades (#5) didn’t get the cozy trip in the Florida Derby that he was afforded when winning the Holy Bull Stakes in February. There’s not a lot of pace signed on for this race, which should allow him to hold his inside position on the front end. The Wine Steward (#2) may prove to be the best of this bunch. He’s making his three year old debut after getting a little bit of a late start to his season. There are likely bigger and better races on his radar, so I do think his connections want to see a good effort. However, he might not be fully cranked up for this race just yet. On deeper tickets, Lucky Jeremy (#10) fits from a pace perspective. He won the Riley Allison Derby and ran decent races in the Sunland Derby and the Jeff Ruby Steaks. The winners of those races, Stronghold and Endlessly, look like serious racehorses. He might be a small cut below the best in the group and 8-1 is a little lower of a price than I’d want to take on him. However, I see him as the sneakiest of the longer priced runners in this race. 

https://inthemoneypodcast.com/road-to-the-2024-kentucky-derby-the-grade-3-stonestreet-lexington-stakes-by-eric-solomon/

Race 11:

The loaded Saturday card ends with a N1X allowance race for three year olds going 1 1/16 miles on the turf, which drew an overflow field of 16. Incinerator (#3) is an interesting runner in this field. He was a winner on debut in a dirt sprint at Tampa and then he followed up that effort with a respectable two turn race on the main track there. He makes his third career start for Arnaud Delacour, who tries him on the turf for the first time. Horses sired by Flameaway have won 24% of the time when making their first start on the turf. In addition, they’ve won 21% of their races in turf routes. For the most part, the dam’s other runners have been dirt horses, however, she was sired by Speightstown and she ran well in her only career turf route. Blinkers go on for the first time for this colt that could be flying under the radar after some decent works on the synthetic. Pletcher makes an interesting move getting Moonlight (#9) back on the grass. He debuted in July on the grass at Saratoga and he just missed that day. The plan was to run back on the grass but the weather had other plans. He ran a huge race to break his maiden at Aqueduct in an off the turf race going one mile. That was good enough to try three straight graded stakes races in his next three starts. He was second to Liberal Arts in a sea of slop in the Street Sense. He was 4th in the Remsen behind three next out winners, including Sierra Leone, Dornoch, and Drum Roll Please. He had a miserable trip at the Fair Grounds in the Risen Star where he finished 9th. That has turned out to be one of the better Derby preps this season so in terms of class, he’s been facing the best horses hands down. Pletcher doesn’t have great numbers going from dirt to turf, but I do think it’s a logical move while facing a field that might not be the strongest field for the condition. Break Out (#13) is going to need a defection to participate, but he has one start and one win on the grass. His dirt form was nothing special, but he started showing some signs of life on synthetic. He broke through at Gulfstream on the grass and that effort was good enough to enter him in the Rushaway Stakes at Turfway last out. He finished 4th, but he came within 1 ½ lengths of the winner. Deadpan (#4) broke his maiden on this course last year, handling the good course well. He struggled in two tries in graded stakes company, but his best effort came at this level two back. He’s been gelded since that last start. Casse seemed content waiting to race him at Keeneland. He gives the reins to Joel Rosario, who has struggled at times at Keeneland.

 

Meet Statistics, Top Pick Winners: 16/54 (29.6%), $112.56, $2.08 ROI

 

How to Read the Picks-Grid:

This grid has become my favorite tool for helping to handicap a race card in advance. Keep in mind that these designations for me are flexible and may change depending on how the value in the betting market shifts leading up to post time. 

 

The “Top Pick” Column is fairly self-explanatory, meaning that it’s the horse that I think will win the race. 

 

The “A” Column is reserved for the horses that I feel have the best chances of winning. The more horses that are in this column per race, the more wide open I think the race might be. For multi-race wagers, these horses will be on the bulk of my tickets. If I’m betting on the vertical wagers (exactas, trifectas, superfectas), these horses would likely be candidates to be keyed on top.

 

The “B” Column are horses that I think have a chance of winning, but I don’t like them as much as the runners on the A line. If I put a morning line favorite in this column, I’m trying to find ways to beat them. For me, favorites on the B line typically will either be used underneath in the vertical exotics, or perhaps not at all. They’ll typically be used on some back up tickets in the multi-race wagers, especially in races where the other options aren’t as strong. I might also relegate a horse to the B line if I don’t think there’s good value on that horse with their morning line odds or how I think the race will be bet. For example, If I think a horse should be closer to 5-1, and their morning line odds are 3-1, he might start on the B line for me. If the betting public moves the line closer to the odds that I feel are fair, and I like the horse’s chances, I could move them up when I’m playing the race. 

 

The “C” Column is reserved as a deep backup for me. Again, if a favorite is on the C line, that’s me telling you that I don’t like them that much in this race. I definitely won’t be using them on top in any vertical wager, as I’ll be trying to beat them with most of my tickets. Sometimes this spot will be reserved for a crazy longshot that checks one of the boxes I might be looking for when playing horses at long odds. 

Share this
Join the discussion

2 comments

Further reading