Maiden Race of the Day: Belmont Park, Race 5, Friday Nov. 20. One maiden race, every angle.

Maiden Race of the Day: Belmont Park Race 5, Friday, Nov. 20

Twelve 2-year-old fillies go 1 1/16 miles on the Belmont Park turf in Race 5 on Friday, a $100,000 maiden special weight with a Beyer par of 70. Nobody has run that fast yet; the top figure is Peaceably’s 67. And most of this field is doing something new. Seven are going a route for the first time (two of them also trying turf), one is debuting and four add blinkers. For each of those firsts, we looked at what the sire’s runners do in turf routes, how far they like to go (the average distance of their wins), what the dam and her other foals did, and what the trainer does in the same spot.

Belmont Park Race 5 | Fri., Nov. 20 | Post time 2:41 p.m. ET | 1 1/16 miles, turf (rail at 36 feet) | $100,000 maiden special weight, 2-year-old fillies

MAIDEN RACE OF THE DAY · In the Money’s free look at the most interesting maiden race on the card, covering pedigrees, sale history, trainer patterns and workouts for breeders and horseplayers alike. See every edition.

TL;DR

  • Doves and Hawks (2/1) has been 2nd twice going long on turf, and the race she lost at Saratoga has since produced a Grade 2-placed filly and a stakes-placed winner. Over five years, Chad Brown’s maidens who ran 2nd last time win 40% in turf routes.
  • Peaceably (4/1) has the top Beyer (67) and is stretching out, and her half-brother Chasing Liberty won mile turf stakes at 2 and 3 on his way to $1,087,406.
  • Critiquer (20/1) comes from the strongest route family in the race: her dam made all 18 starts on turf, and three of her five other foals have won.
  • Mariska (6/1) shares the second-best figure in the field (65), but her trainer is 3-for-88 with maidens in turf routes over five years.

The Field at a Glance

#HorseMLSireTrainerJockeyLast saleBest Beyer
1Shook Up the World30/1Hard SpunTom MorleyEdgard ZayasNone listed50
2Benediction12/1Into MischiefBill MottJose LezcanoNone listed48
3Mariska6/1Knicks GoRudy RodriguezKendrick Carmouche2YO, May ’26, $110K65
4Peaceably4/1EpicenterMichael TrombettaJavier CastellanoHomebred67
5Amphibious12/1Omaha BeachShug McGaugheyP. PenaHomebred52
6Critiquer20/1JustifyRobert RibaudoKatie DavisHomebred50
7Adaptor10/1NyquistS. HampsonJohn VelazquezFT Nov. ’24, $230KDebut
8C’Mon Over Valerie20/1Into MischiefBill MottDylan DavisHomebred38
9Doves and Hawks2/1Twirling CandyChad BrownFlavien PratKeeneland Sept. ’25, $300K65
10D’oro’s Girl12/1Medaglia d’OroLinda RiceVincent CheminaudKeeneland Sept. ’25, $300K57
11Delta Sun20/1Cairo PrinceDavid DonkC. ElliottFT Oct. ’25, $160K29
12Lady Girvin8/1GirvinRick DutrowSamuel MarinOBS April ’26, $70K63
ML = morning line. FT = Fasig-Tipton. Last sale = most recent public auction listed in DRF past performances. Beyers are DRF’s.

#1 Shook Up the World

Hard Spun – One Liz, by Kitalpha

O: Reagan Jack Racing
T: Tom Morley | J: Edgard Zayas

SALES

  • Bred by Dana and Kevin McCreary

Best Beyer: 50 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: turf, going long and blinkers. She was 10th at 56/1 in a 6-furlong maiden on the Belmont synthetic track on Oct. 11 after steadying at the start. Her dam, One Liz, won eight races and $254,671 with a 94 Beyer, but she was much better on synthetic (5 wins from 9 starts) than on turf (3 from 19). Hard Spun’s runners win 13% in turf routes and average 7 1/2 furlongs when they win. Over five years, Morley’s maidens are 0-for-16 when trying turf for the first time in a turf route.

#2 Benediction

Into Mischief – Dunbar Road, by Quality Road

O: Peter M. Brant
T: Bill Mott | J: Jose Lezcano

SALES

  • Bred by White Birch Farm

Best Beyer: 48 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: blinkers. Throw out the debut. In this same race on Oct. 25 she missed the break and was many lengths behind early, made up ground on the backstretch and passed tired horses for 6th at 22/1. The dam is the attraction: Dunbar Road won six races and $1,698,740 with a 103 Beyer, all on dirt, and Benediction’s full brother Collado Hueco won going 1 1/16 miles on dirt with a 98 Beyer. Into Mischief’s runners win 13% in turf routes.

The barn is the problem. Over five years, Mott’s maidens are 3-for-47 when making their second start in a turf route after debuting in one.

#3 Mariska

Knicks Go – Kylee Rose, by Quality Road

O: David Wilkenfeld, Robert Cotrone and Rudy Rodriguez
T: Rudy Rodriguez | J: Kendrick Carmouche

SALES

  • 2-year-old sale, May ’26: $110K (per DRF)
  • California-bred. Bred by DP Racing

Best Beyer: 65 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-1

First time: going long. She’s been 4th at 34/1 and 3rd at 9/1 in two turf sprints here, both solid. The stretch-out is the question. Her dam made one start, and her only other foal to race is a maiden after 11 starts. Knicks Go’s runners win 10% in turf routes, just below the 11% average for all sires. And over five years, Rodriguez’s maidens are 3-for-88 in turf routes, and 1-for-25 when stretching out from sprints.

#4 Peaceably

Epicenter – Peaceful, by Declaration of War

O: Twin Creeks Racing Stables
T: Michael Trombetta | J: Javier Castellano

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Twin Creeks Farm

Best Beyer: 67 | Record: 2 starts, 0-1-0

First time: going long. She has the top figure in the field, a 67 when 2nd at 9/1 in a 7-furlong turf maiden here on Oct. 29, chasing a filly who was loose on the lead. Her first-crop sire, Epicenter, was 2nd in the Kentucky Derby and won the Travers, but his runners so far are better sprinting: 3-for-23 in turf sprints, 3-for-34 in turf routes, and his winners average 6 1/2 furlongs. Her dam, Peaceful, won twice from eight starts, seven of them on turf and all at 6 furlongs or less.

The family says she can go farther. Her half-brother Chasing Liberty (by Constitution) has earned $1,087,406 with a 95 Beyer, nearly all on turf. He won a $204,000 stakes at a mile on the Del Mar turf at 2 and a $100,000 mile turf stakes at Sam Houston at 3, though he’s since found his best form sprinting: he won the Jim McKay Turf Sprint at Laurel in May and was 3rd in the Grade 3 Belmont Turf Sprint on Oct. 1.

Over five years, Trombetta’s maidens win 18% in turf routes, and 21% (5-for-24) when stretching out after turf sprints.

#5 Amphibious

Omaha Beach – Onus, by Blame

O: Stuart S. Janney III
T: Shug McGaughey | J: P. Pena (5-lb apprentice allowance)

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Stuart S. Janney III

Best Beyer: 52 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: going long. She was 8th at 31/1 in her debut, the same Oct. 29 race as Peaceably, after getting floated four wide on the turn. The pedigree says route. Her dam, Onus, won 5 of 11 starts on turf and earned $320,006 with a 98 Beyer. Omaha Beach’s runners win 14% in turf routes, against the 11% average. Over five years, McGaughey’s maidens win 15% (5-for-34) when stretching out from sprints into a turf route, and a $2 bet on each returned $1.93.

#6 Critiquer

Justify – Promotional, by Artie Schiller

O: Marc Keller
T: Robert Ribaudo | J: Katie Davis

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Marc Keller

Best Beyer: 50 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: going long. She was bumped at the start and 9th at 30/1 in that same Oct. 29 sprint. This is the strongest route family in the race. Her dam, Promotional, made all 18 of her starts on turf. Three of the dam’s five other foals have won, and three have earned more than $200,000: Daunt ($423,301), Quarrel ($253,716) and Print ($205,085). When the family wins, it averages 8.7 furlongs. Justify’s runners win 14% in turf routes, and his turf-route winners average 8.8 furlongs. It’s also a family that needs a race: her siblings went 0-for-5 first time out.

Ribaudo is a small stable, with one maiden turf-route win in the last five years.

#7 Adaptor

Nyquist – Smooth Path, by Scat Daddy

O: Repole Stable
T: S. Hampson | J: John Velazquez

SALES

  • Fasig-Tipton Kentucky November ’24 (weanling): $230K (per DRF)
  • Bred by Grantley Acres

Best Beyer: debut | Record: first start

First time: everything. Nyquist’s 2-year-olds win 17% first time out, well above the 11% average, and his runners win 13% in turf routes. Her dam was unraced, but her half-sister Purloin (by Arrogate) won four races and $247,799. Hampson has two starts in DRF’s data, so there’s no pattern to read. Her best work came on Oct. 19 at Belmont, a half-mile that was 5th-fastest of 14 at the distance that day.

#8 C’Mon Over Valerie

Into Mischief – Paris Lights, by Curlin

O: Spendthrift Farm
T: Bill Mott | J: Dylan Davis

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Spendthrift Farm

Best Beyer: 38 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: turf and going long. She was 6th at 14/1 in a 6-furlong dirt maiden on Oct. 23. Her dam, Paris Lights, won four of nine starts and $403,842, all on dirt, and her only other foal to race is a maiden. Over five years, Mott’s maidens are 2-for-48 when making their second start and first on turf in a turf route.

#9 Doves and Hawks

Twirling Candy – Friendly Skies, by Carpe Diem

O: Klaravich Stables
T: Chad Brown | J: Flavien Prat

SALES

  • Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): $300K (per DRF)

Best Beyer: 65 | Record: 2 starts, 0-2-0

The most accomplished filly in the race, with two good 2nds going long on turf. On Aug. 21 at Saratoga she was jostled into the first turn, ran greenly twice and still finished 2nd to Golden Siren, who was then 3rd in the Grade 2 Miss Grillo. The filly behind her, Belmont Street, was then 2nd in a $175,000 stakes and has since won. On Oct. 9 here she was even money, led along the inside, beat off a challenge on the far turn and was caught in the final sixteenth at a mile.

Twirling Candy’s runners win 16% in turf routes. Her dam was unraced. Over five years, Brown’s maidens who ran 2nd in their previous start win 40% (42-for-104) in turf routes.

#10 D’oro’s Girl

Medaglia d’Oro – Tempers Flair, by Smart Strike

O: Team Spoor
T: Linda Rice | J: Vincent Cheminaud

SALES

  • Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): $300K (per DRF)

Best Beyer: 57 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: blinkers. She broke a step slow and trailed in her debut, passing tired horses for 6th at 36/1 in Doves and Hawks’s Oct. 9 race. Medaglia d’Oro’s runners win 13% in turf routes and average 7.6 furlongs when they win. The best of her dam’s foals, though, is a dirt sprinter: half-brother Cowan earned $1,013,032. Over five years, Rice’s maidens win 11% in turf routes.

#11 Delta Sun

Cairo Prince – Ursulina, by More Than Ready

O: David Donk, John Behrendt and partners
T: David Donk | J: C. Elliott

SALES

  • Fasig-Tipton Kentucky October ’25 (yearling): $160K (per DRF)
  • Bred by Circle Bar H

Best Beyer: 29 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

First time: going long, and off 63 days. She broke slowly and trailed in a 6 1/2-furlong turf maiden on Sept. 18. Cairo Prince’s runners win 13% in turf routes. Donk’s maidens win only 8% in turf routes, but seven of his 11 winners came at 10-1 or higher.

#12 Lady Girvin

Girvin – Go Cubs Go, by Paddy O’Prado

O: Jorge Casal
T: Rick Dutrow | J: Samuel Marin

SALES

  • OBS April ’26 (2YO): $70K (per DRF)
  • Bred by Grantley Acres

Best Beyer: 63 | Record: 3 starts, 0-0-1

First time: blinkers. She and Benediction are the only fillies here who have run 1 1/16 miles on this turf course, and she ran well. On Oct. 25 she was bumped on the backstretch, found the rail on the far turn and rallied along it for 3rd at 17/1. Girvin is more of a dirt sire: his runners win 9% in turf routes, against 17% in dirt routes. Over five years, Dutrow’s maidens win 8% in turf routes.

The Prior Races

Oct. 29, Belmont Race 5: maiden special weight, 7 furlongs on turf (Peaceably 2nd, Mariska 3rd, Amphibious 8th, Critiquer 9th). Flow: winner Attachment broke on top and led along the inside the whole way through fast fractions (:45.84 half). It was the lead and the rail; everything else was chasing. Peaceably and Mariska both ran on without a chance to catch her. Amphibious was floated four wide on the turn. No runbacks yet.

Oct. 25, Belmont Race 2: maiden special weight, 1 1/16 miles on turf (Lady Girvin 3rd, Benediction 6th). The same trip as Friday. Flow: the even-money winner, Charlotte’s Beach, controlled a comfortable lead and held off a late rally. Lady Girvin rallied along the rail. Benediction lost many lengths at the start. No runbacks yet.

Oct. 9, Belmont Race 4: maiden special weight, 1 mile on turf (Doves and Hawks 2nd, D’oro’s Girl 6th). Flow: Doves and Hawks led, was pressed on the far turn and was caught late by 20/1 Princess Amari, who came from just off the pace. It’s a common race so far: no winners from three runbacks.

Sept. 18, Belmont Race 3: maiden special weight, 6 1/2 furlongs on turf (Mariska 4th, Lady Girvin 6th, Delta Sun 12th). The form is working out. Inflect (3rd) has won since, the winner Fiora ran in the Grade 2 Miss Grillo, and Mariska and Lady Girvin both ran 3rd next time.

Aug. 21, Saratoga Race 6: maiden special weight, 1 1/16 miles on turf (Doves and Hawks 2nd). The strongest race any of these fillies has run in. Winner Golden Siren went wire to wire, then ran 3rd in the Grade 2 Miss Grillo. Belmont Street (3rd) was 2nd in a $175,000 stakes and has since won a maiden race.

Oct. 11, Belmont Race 5: maiden special weight, 6 furlongs on the synthetic track (Peaceably 5th, Shook Up the World 10th). Peaceably came six to seven wide into the stretch and improved. No winners out of it.

The Verdict

Win: Doves and Hawks. The best form in the race, two honest 2nds going long, and a barn whose maidens win 40% in turf routes after running 2nd. At 2/1 she’s the right favorite.

Value: Peaceably. The top Beyer, a strong turf-sprint trainer pattern stretching out, and a half-brother who won mile turf stakes at 2 and 3. She’s 4/1.

Price play: Critiquer at 20/1. The deepest route pedigree in the field, and a debut she can be excused for.

Use underneath: Lady Girvin (8/1), who has run well at this exact trip, and Amphibious (12/1), whose dam won five times on turf.

Against at the price: Mariska at 6/1. The figures are there, but the trainer is 3-for-88 with maidens in turf routes.

Exacta idea: Doves and Hawks and Peaceably, both ways, with Critiquer, Lady Girvin and Amphibious.

How we did this

  • Field, conditions, morning lines, past performances and works: DRF Formulator.
  • Beyer Speed Figures: Daily Racing Form.
  • Sire stats: DRF Formulator progeny summaries (North American starts), including each sire’s average winning distance.
  • Dams and siblings: DRF Formulator dam pages and sibling past performances. Sibling records don’t include the horse in this race.
  • Trainer stats: five years of DRF Formulator trainer data (Nov. 2021 to Nov. 2026), counting only horses that debuted for that trainer, in maiden races. Turf routes are turf races at a mile or more.
  • Sales: sale lines as printed in DRF past performances.
  • Race checks: DRF charts for every prior race, with each runner’s next start.

More Maiden Race of the Day: Thursday’s Belmont Race 5 · Wednesday’s Churchill Race 9 · every Maiden Race of the Day. PTF’s picks for the whole card are in his Friday Belmont analysis, every ITM pick for Friday is on Friday’s Racing hub and Today’s Racing, and the rest of our Belmont handicapping is in our Belmont Park coverage.

Share this

Want more picks like these? Get the ITM Players' Newsletter, free

Picks, contest tips and the best plays from the ITM team, in your inbox every week.

Want more? ITM Plus adds notes for the big cards, Steven Bonnick's shipping alerts, horses to watch and members-only handicapping podcasts. $49 a month or $249 a year.

Join the discussion

Further reading