Maiden Race of the Day: Churchill Downs Race 9, Wednesday Nov. 18

Maiden Race of the Day: Churchill Downs Race 9, Wednesday, Nov. 18

Ten 2-year-old fillies go 1 1/16 miles on the Churchill Downs dirt in Race 9 on Wednesday, a $50,000 maiden claimer with a Beyer par of 58. Nobody in the field has run that fast yet; the top figure is a 53. That makes this a race about trainers. Five of the 10 are dropping from maiden special weights into a claimer for the first time, and every one of their barns has a five-year record we can check. There’s also the full sister to a Kentucky Derby starter, a filly who moved into a fast pace at this level last time, and one who came out of a race that has produced three next-out winners.

Churchill Downs Race 9 | Wed., Nov. 18 | Post time 4:55 p.m. ET | 1 1/16 miles, dirt | $50,000 maiden claiming, 2-year-old fillies | Purse $67,000

MAIDEN RACE OF THE DAY · In the Money’s free look at the most interesting maiden race on the card, covering pedigrees, sale history, trainer patterns and workouts for breeders and horseplayers alike. See every edition.

TL;DR

  • Batcycle (5/2) drops in for Eddie Kenneally, whose first-time droppers win 24%, and that improves to 32% when they’re bet under 5-1. She’s a full sister to Kentucky Derby starter Render Judgment, and her last race has produced two winners and two seconds.
  • Upside Out (8/1) moved into a fast pace at this level last time, led at the quarter pole at 45/1 and held 4th when the rest of the pace collapsed.
  • Go Missy Go (4/1) has the top Beyer (53), earned in a much faster $150,000 maiden claimer, and Rodolphe Brisset’s maidens win 23% in claimers at Churchill.
  • Kabin Eight (12/1) came out of a $50,000 maiden claimer here that has produced three next-out winners.

The Field at a Glance

#HorseMLSireTrainerJockeyLast saleBest Beyer
1Elowyn’s Honor10/1Honor A. P.Troy NewtonDanny SheehyHomebred48
2Silk Street8/1UpstartSarah ShafferJaime A. TorresOBS June ’26, $30K43
3Freshair30/1Mo DonegalBrian WaltzDylan MachadoHomebred31
4Cover Story9/2Thousand WordsKenny McPeekEmmanuel EsquivelFT Oct. ’25, $22K37
5Batcycle5/2BlameEddie KenneallyLuis SaezHomebred49
6Upside Out8/1UpstartMark CasseYomar Ortiz Jr.Homebred45
7Doctor Approved6/1Bolt d’OroBret CalhounBrian Hernandez Jr.Keeneland Sept. ’25, $65K48
8Kabin Eight12/1Cairo PrinceWilliam CowansLuan MachadoHomebred44
9Go Missy Go4/1Knicks GoRodolphe BrissetCristian A. TorresHomebred53
10Waawaatesi20/1Mo DonegalLacy PierceJulien LeparouxKeeneland Sept. ’25, RNA $25K19
ML = morning line. FT = Fasig-Tipton. RNA = bought back (reserve not attained). Last sale = most recent public auction. Beyers are DRF’s. All 10 run for a $50,000 claiming price.

#1 Elowyn’s Honor

Honor A. P. – St. Louise, by Curlin

O: Barrett Partners
T: Troy Newton | J: Danny Sheehy

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Barrett Partners

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 48 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-0

She drops in for the first time after two maiden special weights at long odds: 6th at 40/1 on the Kentucky Downs turf and 6th at 45/1 going 1 1/16 miles on the Keeneland dirt, breaking slowly both times. Her dam, St. Louise, raced for the same owner and trainer and was 0-for-15 with four seconds. Honor A. P.’s runners win 13% of their dirt routes, about average. Newton’s maiden claimers win 19%, though he has rarely dropped a maiden into a claimer for the first time.

#2 Silk Street

Upstart – Grammajo, by Street Sense

O: Jarvis Racing Stable
T: Sarah Shaffer | J: Jaime A. Torres

SALES

  • Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): catalogued, no sale recorded. Vinery Sales, agent
  • Fasig-Tipton Kentucky October ’25 (yearling): RNA at $95K. Vinery Sales, agent
  • OBS Spring ’26 (2YO): outed
  • OBS June ’26 (2YO): $30K, after a :10 2/5 breeze. Omar Ramirez Bloodstock, agent → Ron Jarvis
  • Bred in Kentucky by Brandon Trosclair and Chris Jean

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 43 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

She bought back at $95,000 as a yearling and sold for $30,000 eight months later. Her lone start was a 4th at 25/1 in a 6-furlong maiden special weight here on Sept. 18, waiting behind the leaders and then swinging six wide. The filly she beat for 4th, Soccer Socks, came back to run 3rd at this level, ahead of Upside Out and Cover Story. Blinkers go on, and she stretches out.

The family is quick: her dam’s five foals have won 5 of 14 races at 2 (35%), but they’re sprinters, 10% in dirt routes. Upstart’s runners win 16% in dirt routes. This is the first time in five years Shaffer has dropped a maiden into a claimer.

#3 Freshair

Mo Donegal – Star Affair, by Tiznow

O: Milt Policzer
T: Brian Waltz | J: Dylan Machado

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Milt Policzer

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 31 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

She was 6th at 30/1 in a 5 1/2-furlong maiden at Horseshoe Indianapolis in her only start, improving late from the 4-path, and she’s her unraced dam’s first runner. Her sire, 2022 Belmont Stakes winner Mo Donegal, has his first crop racing, and so far they’re sprinters: his winners average under 6 furlongs, and he’s 1-for-9 in dirt routes. Waltz’s first-time droppers are 1-for-11.

#4 Cover Story

Thousand Words – Jordy’s Ready, by More Than Ready

O: Magdalena Racing (Sherri McPeek) and partners
T: Kenny McPeek | J: Emmanuel Esquivel

SALES

  • Keeneland November ’24 (weanling): $8K. Taylor Made, agent for the Erv Woolsey estate → Shorty Bloodstock
  • Fasig-Tipton Kentucky October ’25 (yearling): $22K. Denali Stud, agent → Kenneth McPeek, agent

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 37 | Record: 1 start, 0-0-0

McPeek bought her cheap. Her full sister Ribadeo sold for $150,000 at OBS in the spring of 2025, after a :10 1/5 breeze. She debuted for this same $50,000 tag at Keeneland on Oct. 23, got bumped at the start, shied into the first turn, lacked speed and picked up pieces late for 5th at 12/1. That race collapsed (see below), so her late gain flatters her. Her dam won twice in 15 starts, with a best Beyer of 58.

McPeek’s first-time droppers win 40% when bet under 5-1, but Cover Story isn’t one. She debuted for a tag, and his maidens making a second start after a claiming debut are 3-for-37 (8%).

#5 Batcycle

Blame – Barbara Gordon, by Commissioner

O: Green Lantern Stables
T: Eddie Kenneally | J: Luis Saez

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Green Lantern Stables

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 49 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-0

The pedigree story of the race. Her full brother Render Judgment has earned $408,205 with a 94 Beyer for McPeek, ran in the 2025 Kentucky Derby and the Grade 1 Blue Grass, and was 2nd in the Virginia Derby. He won at 1 3/16 miles here in June. Blame’s runners win 16% in dirt routes. This is a filly bred to go long, running for a $50,000 tag.

Her form has a story too. On Oct. 10 at Keeneland she checked between horses at the start, was 10th early in a mile turf maiden run at a slow pace and rallied to 7th at 60/1 with a 49 Beyer. Four fillies from that race have run back: two won here on Nov. 8, and two ran 2nd here that weekend. Her dirt debut, 8th at 40/1 at a mile here on Sept. 13, produced only a 33.

Kenneally is 9-for-36 (25%) since Oct. 1. Over five years, his maidens dropping from special weights into a claimer for the first time are 13-for-55 (24%), and that improves to 32% (12-for-37) when they’re bet under 5-1. At 5-1 or higher they’re 1-for-18. Saez rides.

#6 Upside Out

Upstart – Koto, by More Than Ready

O: Gabe Grossberg
T: Mark Casse | J: Yomar Ortiz Jr. (apprentice, 7 pounds off)

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Gabe Grossberg

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 45 | Record: 4 starts, 0-0-0

The run to watch from the Oct. 23 race at this level. The early pace went in :22.90 and :47.63 for a mile, and it collapsed: the first three came from 12th, 7th and 8th. Upside Out was the only filly to move into that pace and stay. She went from 8th to the lead at the quarter pole at 45/1, got caught between two closers at the sixteenth pole and held 4th with a career-best 45. Three earlier starts in maiden special weights produced nothing.

She’s the first foal of Koto, who raced for the same owner and trainer and didn’t win. Casse’s maidens making a second start in a claimer win 16%, and that improves to 25% (10-for-40) when they finished 4th or better in the first one. The catch: his maiden claimers at Churchill are 2-for-49 over five years.

#7 Doctor Approved

Bolt d’Oro – Lijana, by Hard Spun

O: Kat Kirk and Wayne R. Sanders
T: Bret Calhoun | J: Brian Hernandez Jr.

SALES

  • Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): $65K. Stone Farm, agent → Wayne Sanders and Kat Kirk

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 48 | Record: 4 starts, 0-1-0

She has already run twice in $50,000 maiden optional claimers at Ellis Park, finishing 2nd at 5/2 on a sloppy track in August. Then Calhoun sent her back to a maiden special weight here on Sept. 20, a key race (the winner, Oh She Said Yes, ran 3rd in the Grade 1 Alcibiades). She stalked along the inside and stopped to finish 10th at 45/1. Her best figure, a 48, came in her 4 1/2-furlong debut.

Her dam, Lijana, won once and ran an 80 Beyer for Cherie DeVaux; this is her first runner. Calhoun’s maiden claimers win 22% in dirt routes and 17% at Churchill. But his maidens going back into a claimer after another try in a special weight are 0-for-15.

#8 Kabin Eight

Cairo Prince – No Pity, by Into Mischief

O: PTK
T: William Cowans | J: Luan Machado

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by PTK. Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): catalogued, no sale recorded

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 44 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-0

She came out of the strongest race anyone in this field has run at this level. On Sept. 10 here, in a 6-furlong $50,000 maiden claimer, she was 5th at 15/1 after going eight wide into the stretch. Three fillies from that race won next out: Maddy Mania (3rd that day), who then beat Upside Out and Cover Story at Keeneland; Peace Mission, who won at Woodbine; and Sharply, who won at Horseshoe Indianapolis.

She’s been off since and stretches out for the first time. Her dam never raced, but her half-sister Unrelenting won a maiden claimer for Cowans, and her half-sister by Omaha Beach sold to McPeek for $200,000 at Keeneland in September. Cowans’ maiden claimers win 24%, but at Churchill they’re 1-for-19.

#9 Go Missy Go

Knicks Go – Missap, by A. P. Warrior

O: Beckett Racing Team
T: Rodolphe Brisset | J: Cristian A. Torres

SALES

  • Homebred. Bred by Beckett Racing Team in Kentucky

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 53 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-1

The top figure in the field. She was 3rd at 7/1 in a 5 1/2-furlong maiden at Horseshoe Indianapolis, then 6th at 10/1 in a $150,000 maiden claimer at Keeneland on Oct. 21, bumped twice early. That race was far faster than this one: the winner, Jackie and Ginger, went wire to wire, drew off and ran an 82.

Today the tag drops by two-thirds and she stretches from 6 1/2 furlongs to 1 1/16 miles. Her dam, Missap, won five races and $243,671 for the same owners with a 74 Beyer, and Missap’s runners win 22% in dirt routes. Brisset’s maidens dropping into a claimer for the first time win 42% under 5-1, and his maiden claimers at Churchill win 23% (9-for-39).

#10 Waawaatesi

Mo Donegal – Qualkris, by Malibu Moon

O: Denise M. Dillon
T: Lacy Pierce | J: Julien Leparoux

SALES

  • Keeneland Sept. ’25 (yearling): RNA at $25K. Kaizen Sales, agent
  • Bred by Denise M. Dillon

Claiming tag: $50,000 | Best Beyer: 19 | Record: 2 starts, 0-0-0

The family is selling well: her half-brother by Taiba brought $185,000 at Keeneland in September, and another half-brother, Paddy Dillon, sold for $140,000 at OBS in 2025. Her dam’s foals have earned $576,891. On the track she has a 19 Beyer from two starts, including a 9th here on Sept. 18 after being bumped and carried out at the start. Blinkers go on for the drop. Pierce hasn’t won a race since December 2025.

The Prior Races

Oct. 23, Keeneland Race 3: $50,000 maiden claimer, 1 mile (Upside Out 4th, Cover Story 5th). The same level and nearly the same trip. Flow: a fast pace (:22.90, :47.63) that fell apart. The pacesetter was eased and the first three came from 12th, 7th and 8th. That flatters Cover Story’s late gain and makes Upside Out’s run, the only move into the pace that held, the best effort.

Sept. 10, Churchill Race 1: $50,000 maiden claimer, 6 furlongs (Kabin Eight 5th). A key race: three next-out winners. Flow: winner Shinobu went wire to wire on a good track, so the closers were up against it. Kabin Eight went eight wide into the stretch.

Oct. 10, Keeneland Race 7: maiden special weight, 1 mile on turf (Batcycle 7th). A key race: Fifth Peg and Shelley B both won here on Nov. 8, and Just Peachy and Viaggio both ran 2nd next out. Flow: a slow pace (:49.67 half), which made it hard to close. Batcycle checked at the start, sat 10th and rallied to 7th.

Sept. 18, Churchill Race 7: maiden special weight, 6 furlongs (Silk Street 4th, Waawaatesi 9th). No winners out of it yet. Tapit Nitro, 2nd that day, dropped to $50,000 on Nov. 4 at 2/1 and ran 8th. Soccer Socks, 5th behind Silk Street, was 3rd at this level next out.

Oct. 21, Keeneland Race 3: $150,000 maiden claimer, 6 1/2 furlongs (Go Missy Go 6th). A fast race, with an 82 Beyer for the winner.

The Verdict

Win: Batcycle. The best pedigree for 1 1/16 miles, a key race behind her, and a trainer whose first-time droppers win 32% when bet.

Value: Upside Out. She ran the best race at this level of anyone in the field, against the flow, and she’s 8/1. Casse’s poor record with maiden claimers at Churchill keeps her out of the top spot.

The one to beat if she’s bet: Go Missy Go. Top figure, a big drop in class, and Brisset’s first-time droppers win 42% under 5-1. The stretch-out is the question.

Use with caution: Cover Story. The late run last time came off a collapsing pace, and McPeek’s maidens making a second start after a claiming debut win 8%.

Watch the board: Kabin Eight. She ran in the key race at this level, but she’s stretching out off a two-month break for a barn that’s 1-for-19 with maiden claimers here. At 12/1 or more, a small saver; if she’s taking money, use her.

Exacta idea: Batcycle over Upside Out, Go Missy Go and Silk Street.

How we did this

  • Field, conditions, morning lines, past performances and works: DRF Formulator.
  • Beyer Speed Figures: Daily Racing Form.
  • Trainer stats: five years of DRF Formulator trainer data (Nov. 2021 to Nov. 2026), counting only horses that debuted for that trainer. “First-time droppers” are maidens making their first start in a maiden claimer after running only in maiden special weights.
  • Sire and family stats: DRF Formulator progeny summaries and dam pages (North American starts).
  • Sales: Keeneland, Fasig-Tipton and OBS sale records.
  • Race checks: DRF charts for every prior race, with each runner’s next start.
  • Render Judgment: DRF past performances; Kentucky Derby start confirmed in race coverage.

More Maiden Race of the Day: Sunday’s Churchill Race 10 · Saturday’s Belmont Race 5 · every Maiden Race of the Day. Today’s picks from the whole ITM team are on the Today’s Racing page, and the rest of our Churchill handicapping is in our Churchill Downs coverage.

Share this

Want more picks like these? Get the ITM Players' Newsletter, free

Picks, contest tips and the best plays from the ITM team, in your inbox every week.

Want more? ITM Plus adds notes for the big cards, Steven Bonnick's shipping alerts, horses to watch and members-only handicapping podcasts. $49 a month or $249 a year.

Join the discussion

Further reading